Both papers have a Table 1 listing mean incomes by stakeholder group. In the 2023 paper in Forest Policy and Economics, the groups are people interviewed in Bangladesh’s Sundarban mangrove forest. In the 2025 paper in Land Use Policy, they are people interviewed in Baiquan, in the black-soil farmland of northeast China. Lisa Lobry de Bruyn of the University of New England in Australia coauthored the 2023 paper, and she says the two tables show identical mean incomes for identical participant groups, along with other similar values, Retraction Watch reported on November 9.
She sent that comparison to the editors of both journals on December 2, 2025. Within days, the authors of the Chinese paper asked to retract it. They also denied plagiarism. This case has now run 11 months. An Elsevier representative told Retraction Watch that the investigation “is ongoing and we are unable to provide any further details at this stage.” As of November 10, the paper’s Crossref record listed no correction, retraction or expression of concern, and the Retraction Watch report mentions none.
Two countries, one set of incomes
The two studies cover different countries, ecosystems and populations, and each claims its own fieldwork. Lobry de Bruyn told Retraction Watch that after she read the newer paper and “saw the figures and methods were very similar with just a change in location and context,” the “alarm bells rang.” Her complaint goes back further, to a 2021 study in the Journal of Environmental Management by the same Bangladesh team. Retraction Watch’s side-by-side images pair figure 3 of that paper with figure 3 of the 2025 paper, and figure 1 with figure 2. According to Lobry de Bruyn, neither is credited.
Zheng Cai, first author of the 2025 paper at Northeast Agricultural University in Harbin, has an answer for each point. His paper “openly cites Begum et al.” The citation exists: the Crossref reference list includes the 2023 Forest Policy and Economics paper, though not the 2021 study whose figures are in dispute. He says the figures were redrawn “entirely based on our own study sites, institutional actors and stakeholder data.” He says the work was developed independently and is “fully traceable through our project materials,” including interview records, NVivo coding files and iThenticate reports. He attributes the resemblance to a widely used co-management framework. The retraction request, he said, was “not an admission of any research misconduct or plagiarism.”
A shared framework can explain shared headings, themes and diagrams of who governs what. It does not obviously explain why stakeholders in a Bangladeshi mangrove forest and on Chinese farmland would report the same mean incomes. iThenticate is a text-similarity checker, so a clean report on the wording of a manuscript says nothing about where the numbers in a table came from. An interview transcript proves an interview happened, which is a different question from whether the published figures were drawn from it. The investigation has to settle whether the authors’ records actually produce the numbers in their Table 1. The authors have said those records exist.
The file, by date
On December 2, 2025, Lobry de Bruyn emailed Uchendu Chigbu, co-editor-in-chief of Land Use Policy at the Namibia University of Science and Technology, and Lukas Giessen, editor-in-chief of Forest Policy and Economics at the University of Göttingen. The next day, according to Retraction Watch, Chigbu wrote to Cai about “serious plagiarism allegations” and copied an Elsevier employee.
Cai replied for the authors on December 4, denying wrongdoing and asking in the same message that the paper be retracted. He wanted, he wrote, to “uphold the highest standards of academic integrity and ensure the accuracy and robustness of our findings,” because the framework “could be further improved and refined” and some empirical parts needed more verification.
Chigbu answered on December 5 that “we would not be able to retract the published article on the grounds you have stated,” because the authors had not addressed the plagiarism concern, and he asked them to respond to the allegations directly. His refusal kept the actual allegation at the center of the file and denied the authors a retraction framed around their own reasons.
That email, Retraction Watch reports, was the last time Lobry de Bruyn heard from the journal. Cai says he has heard nothing from Land Use Policy or Elsevier since December. Flora Begum, Lobry de Bruyn’s then-Ph.D. student on the 2023 paper and now at Bangladesh Agricultural University, put the problem plainly: “This raises serious questions about academic integrity and the rigour of the review process.”
The notice Elsevier’s policy provides for
Elsevier’s article withdrawal, retraction and expression of concern policy covers this situation. It lets editors issue an expression of concern in three circumstances, one of which reads: “An investigation is underway, but a judgment will not be available for a considerable time.” The notice “remains part of the permanent record,” and if the case is later resolved, the original “will not be removed but may be updated.” Under the policy, journal editors make the decision “in consultation with Elsevier’s Research Integrity & Publishing Ethics Center of Expertise.”
The Committee on Publication Ethics, whose guidance was revised in 2025, gives a more concrete trigger. As Retraction Watch reported at the time, COPE says an expression of concern should be published when an investigation or resolution will take “some time (eg several months).” Retraction itself is a separate question: once an editor is convinced a paper “is seriously flawed, misleading” or otherwise unreliable, COPE wants the notice out “as soon as possible.” No editor has said publicly that this paper meets that bar. Andrew Grey called COPE’s timing recommendation “too vague,” adding: “Currently it can take many months.”
Several months passed long ago. An expression of concern does not require a verdict, only that readers be told a question is open, and the publisher’s own rules list a slow investigation as one of the reasons to issue one.
The paper carries Chinese public money. Its Crossref record lists the National Key Research and Development Program of China, award 2024YFD1500901, and the National Social Science Fund of China. Elsevier’s parent company is not short of resources. In RELX’s 2025 results, revenue was £9,590 million, adjusted operating profit was £3,342 million and the adjusted operating margin was 34.8 percent. Chief executive Erik Engstrom cited “good growth with improving momentum in Scientific, Technical & Medical.” The same release’s forward-looking statements list “research integrity issues” among the factors that could make results differ from expectations.
None of that explains why no notice has been issued, and the documents do not say. What they do show is a publisher that tells investors research integrity is a business risk, has a written mechanism for warning readers during a slow investigation, and has left this paper without one for nearly a year. Anyone who cites the Baiquan income figures in the meantime gets no warning that the people who collected the original Sundarban numbers say those figures are theirs.
The decision belongs to Chigbu and his co-editors at Land Use Policy, working with Elsevier’s Research Integrity & Publishing Ethics Center of Expertise. They have the complaint, the authors’ denial and the authors’ offer of interview records and coding files. Giessen has had a complaint about work published in his own journal since December 2. No expression of concern has been issued, and nobody has given a date for a finding.
Sources
- Retraction Watch, November 9, 2026
- Land Use Policy: Cai, Li, Du and Li, “Integrating co-management in black soil conservation: Stakeholders’ perspectives in Baiquan, China” (2025)
- Forest Policy and Economics: Begum, Lobry de Bruyn, Kristiansen and Islam, “Development pathways for co-management in the Sundarban mangrove forest: A multiple stakeholder perspective” (2023)
- Journal of Environmental Management: Begum, Lobry de Bruyn, Kristiansen and Islam, “Institutionalising co-management activities for conservation of forest resources” (2021)
- Crossref metadata record for Cai et al. 2025, DOI 10.1016/j.landusepol.2025.107809
- Elsevier’s article withdrawal, retraction and expression of concern policy
- Retraction Watch: New COPE retraction guidelines address paper mills, third parties, and more (Sept. 4, 2025)
- RELX: 2025 Results