On May 5, 2014, the director-general of the World Health Organization declared the international spread of poliovirus a public health emergency of international concern, the formal alarm the agency can sound under the International Health Regulations. Twelve years later the polio emergency is still running. It has lasted because an emergency committee meets every three months and has to conclude, again, that the risk of spread justifies keeping it, and the 45th of those meetings was held this May. The review clock is clumsy, but it’s the one moment when someone has to argue out loud that the emergency still exists.
That clock is what a group of climate and health researchers now want to build around. The Lancet Countdown, whose tenth annual report came out on October 28 with 146 experts tracking 54 indicators, wants climate change “formally recognised as a global health emergency,” in the words of executive director Marina Romanello. The authors want WHO to create a new instrument to make that recognition official, Health Policy Watch reports, because the existing emergency mechanism, Romanello says, is “tailored to short-lived emergencies and especially to emergencies that can cross borders.” According to Gavi’s summary of the report, the new tool would focus on long-term action and resilience rather than acute crises like Ebola. Until it exists, the authors want WHO and the UN to use existing tools, the International Health Regulations among them, to grade and respond to climate-driven health crises.
Euronews’ account of what the designation is meant to accomplish is blunt: it would “shift global climate action from slow, voluntary commitments to mandatory, coordinated emergency management,” with legally binding accountability mechanisms. Alongside it sit recommendations for an immediate global ban on new fossil fuel exploration and exploitation, the complete phase-out of coal-fired power by 2035, and a shift toward predominantly plant-based diets. None of the published descriptions of the proposal say who would be bound, who would enforce the accountability, how often anyone would review the emergency, or what would end it. For a crisis its own advocates measure in decades, those are the terms that decide what kind of power is being requested.
The Countdown is no outside petitioner, either. It was created in 2016, the year the Paris Agreement came into force, as The Lancet’s editorial marking its tenth year notes. Its report runs in The Lancet, its work is funded by the Wellcome Trust under a project record that runs to April 2029, and it was produced working with WHO, the agency it’s asking to take on the new instrument.
Three scientists and a secret committee
We’ve watched WHO manage a declared emergency before, and the details turned out to matter. In 2009, as the agency handled H1N1 swine flu as a pandemic, many governments already held pandemic vaccine contracts, which industry representative Luc Hessel said existed so nobody had to negotiate in the middle of a crisis. The following June, the BMJ and the Bureau of Investigative Journalism reported that three scientists who wrote key sections of WHO’s 2004 pandemic influenza guidance had financial ties to the companies selling the countermeasures. Fred Hayden, author of the antivirals section, said Roche, the maker of Tamiflu, was paying him for lectures and consulting at the time, and Arnold Monto and Karl Nicholson had declared money from Roche and GlaxoSmithKline. They had disclosed those ties elsewhere, but WHO never disclosed them when it issued the guidance. The agency kept the names of its H1N1 Emergency Committee private, and Director-General Margaret Chan turned down the BMJ’s request for the conflict declarations from the 2004 meeting.
WHO rejected any suggestion of undue pharmaceutical influence. Michael Osterholm, defending the agency, said “There’s no evidence whatever that any of these individuals acted improperly, nor did WHO.” The Council of Europe’s parliamentary assembly was harsher, and its report by British MP Paul Flynn called the response an “unjustified scare” and cited “grave shortcomings” in transparency. Nobody proved a decision was bought. What 2009 did establish is that a declaration sets contracts and authority in motion, so the rules about who advises, who discloses and who calls it off are where accountability either exists or doesn’t.
Heat, mosquitoes and highland malaria
Some of what the Countdown documents is serious harm, and it deserves a straight reading. The report estimates heat was linked to an average of 540,800 deaths a year from 2016 to 2023, with 68% attributed to climate change, up from 55% in 2006–2015. In 2023 the toll reached a record 710,000 heat-linked deaths, 71.5% of them attributed to warming, which the report says is more than malaria or HIV. These are model estimates that assign a share of heat deaths to human-caused warming, not tallies from death certificates, and they should be read that way.
The infectious-disease findings show how warming actually moves disease. Aedes aegypti, the dengue mosquito, does better in heat, and the virus copies itself faster inside a warm insect, so 2024’s record 14.4 million dengue cases fits a pattern the Countdown has tracked for a decade. Malaria is more instructive. Suitability for Plasmodium falciparum rose 12.88% in highland areas of WHO’s African region between 1981–90 and 2015–25, while some tropical lowlands are becoming too hot for transmission. The parasite is climbing hills and leaving valleys, which is a surveillance job for particular health ministries watching particular districts.
The report’s own success stories follow the same pattern. Increases in people affected by storms and floods were 8.6% lower in countries with health early warning systems, a comparison between countries rather than a controlled trial, but a striking one. Health adaptation plans grew from 14 WHO member states in 2015 to 56 in 2025. Cleaner energy prevented an estimated 400,000 deaths in 2023 compared with 2016, mainly through better indoor air quality, and clean energy investment hit a record $2.1 trillion in 2025, 82% more than fossil fuel investment. Every one of those gains came under existing arrangements, built by national governments using their own authority. The people asking for a standing emergency haven’t shown what it would add to that list, and the burden of showing it belongs to them.
The speeches went quiet
The Countdown also documents its own political problem. The share of countries linking climate and health in their UN General Debate speeches fell from 65.9% in 2021 to 26.3% in 2025. Diarmid Campbell-Lendrum, who leads WHO’s climate and health work, offered one explanation at a webinar on climate disinformation, comparing today’s tactics to the ones that once deflected blame from tobacco: “exactly the same tactics, and even in some cases the same players.”
Speech counts don’t measure public trust, but the timing points to a simpler explanation than oil-industry spin. Those were the years governments came out of COVID, an emergency with WHO at its center. In July 2021, Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus conceded a “premature push” to rule out a lab leak in Wuhan, months after his agency’s own March report had called that origin “extremely unlikely,” and the AP noted he had repeatedly praised China for its speed and transparency even as senior WHO officials privately complained about obfuscation. A government that watched the agency wave away the most consequential question of the pandemic and then walk it back has good reason to hesitate before granting that agency an emergency built to last decades.
Washington stopped hesitating. President Trump signed Executive Order 14155 on January 20, 2025, and the United States formally exited WHO on January 22, 2026, with HHS citing “profound failures” in the handling of COVID-19 and the agency’s “lack of accountability, transparency, and independence.” The US had been paying assessed dues averaging about $111 million a year and voluntary contributions of roughly $570 million. Six months before the exit, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Marco Rubio rejected the 2024 amendments to the International Health Regulations, calling their terminology “vague and broad” and warning of “unwarranted interference with our national sovereign right to make health policy.” “We will not tolerate international policies that infringe on Americans’ speech, privacy, or personal liberties,” they said. A proposal that leads with legally binding accountability and leaves its terms unwritten gives that objection more to work with.
The Countdown counts the fallout as part of the crisis. Health aid from the 17 largest donors is projected to fall by more than $50 billion, about 25%, between 2023 and 2026, “led by the withdrawal by the United States,” per Health Policy Watch. That figure covers development assistance for health across all channels, a far bigger pot than anything Washington sent WHO directly, and it reflects a government that decided the institutions spending its money had failed to answer for how they spent it.
COP31 opens in Antalya, Türkiye, this month, and health delegates will arrive carrying the Countdown’s numbers. The next test comes at WHO itself: whether any member state carries the proposed instrument to the Executive Board or to the World Health Assembly next May, rooms the United States will no longer sit in. If a government does sponsor it, the text will have to answer the question the polio committee faces every three months and 2009 never settled: who decides when the emergency is over?
Sources
- Lancet Countdown 2026 report
- Health Policy Watch, Oct. 28, 2026
- Gavi VaccinesWork summary of the 2026 Lancet Countdown
- The Lancet editorial: Climate change and health, 10 years on, what next?
- Euronews, Oct. 28, 2026
- Global Polio Eradication Initiative: public health emergency status
- CIDRAP, June 2010: BMJ, European group criticize WHO pandemic actions
- AP via ABC News 4, July 15, 2021: WHO chief says it was premature to rule out COVID lab leak
- HHS/CDC fact sheet on U.S. withdrawal from WHO
- Al Jazeera, July 18, 2025
- University of Birmingham: Lancet Countdown project record